immersionlog

Quoting, thinking and reporting: と

How Japanese reports what someone said, thought or asked, with direct and indirect quotes, 〜と思う, 〜って, という, かどうか and the grammar of naming things.

About 6 minutes to read

Narration is full of people saying and thinking things. Japanese handles this with the particle と, which closes a quotation and tells you what the next verb is about.

Direct quotes

Put the exact words in 「」 brackets and add と plus the verb of saying or thinking:

彼かれheは 「行いく」"I'm going"と(quote)言いったsaid
He said, "I'm going."
先生せんせいteacherは 「静しずかにquietlyして」 と(quote)言いったsaid
The teacher said, "Be quiet."

The brackets are often replaced by plain commas or nothing at all in normal text. To find a quote, look for と followed by 言う, 思う, 聞く, 書く, 考える, 答える.

Reported speech, without changing the grammar

Unlike English, Japanese does not shift tenses or pronouns when reporting. The quoted words stay in the form they were said in (plain form, usually):

彼かれheは 明日あしたtomorrow来くるcomeと(quote)言いったsaid
He said that he'd come tomorrow.

The quote is literally "tomorrow come". Yet the sentence is reported speech. No "would", no backshifting.

と思う: I think that

Plain form + と思う is how you give your own opinion or guess. It's one of the most useful patterns in the language.

彼かれheは 来くるcomeと思おもうI think
I think he'll come.
この 映画えいがmovieは 面白おもしろいinterestingと思おもうI think
I think this movie is interesting.
彼かれheは 来こないdoesn't comeと思おもうI think
I think he won't come.Japanese often puts the negative inside the quote ("I think he won't come"), not outside ("I don't think he'll come").

Use 〜と思っている for a thought you hold now and 〜と思った for what you thought at some point:

合格ごうかくしたpassedと思おもったI thought
I thought I'd passed.

For the thoughts of others, use 〜と思っている:

彼かれheは 勝かてるcan winと思おもっているthinks
He thinks he can win.

Plain-form shorthand: って

In casual speech, と shortens to って, and 〜と言った becomes 〜って言った:

彼かれheが 行いくgoって(quote)言いったsaid
He said he's going.
田中たなかTanakaってcalled人ひとperson
a person called Tanaka / this Tanaka person

A sentence ending in って can also mean "I heard that..." or "they say...":

明日あしたtomorrow雨あめrainだって(I hear)
I hear it'll rain tomorrow.

という: called, named

という ("saying that") links a name or a statement to a noun:

山田やまだYamadaというcalled人ひとperson
a person called Yamada
彼かれheが 来くるcomeというthat話はなしstory
the story that he's coming
「 ありがとう」 というthat言葉ことばword
the word "thank you"

It's a regular part of describing clauses. When a noun like 話, 噂, 考え, 夢, 気持ち is explained by a full sentence, the sentence connects with という.

Quoting questions: かどうか and か

To report a question you've heard or are asking yourself, add か. A yes/no question uses かどうか ("whether or not").

彼かれheが 来くるcomeかどうかwhether分わからないdon't know
I don't know if he's coming.
何時なんじwhat timeに 始はじまるstartか(question)教おしえてtellください 
Please tell me what time it starts.

The question is in plain form followed by か, without the question mark.

〜そうだ: I heard that (hearsay)

Plain form + そうだ reports what you have heard from someone or something else:

天気予報てんきよほうweather forecastに よるaccordingと 明日あしたtomorrowは 雨あめrainだそうだI hear
According to the weather forecast, it will rain tomorrow.
彼かれheは 結婚けっこんするmarryそうだI heard
I heard that he's getting married.

Be careful: plain form + そうだ is hearsay, but stem + そうだ means "looks like" (おいしそうだ looks delicious). We'll compare these in the lesson on guessing and appearance.

Reading dialogue in books

In novels you'll see lines like this:

「今日きょうtodayは 寒さむいcoldね」 と 彼女かのじょsheは 言いったsaid
"It's cold today," she said.

The quote, then と, then the speaker, then the verb of saying. Often the speaker and verb come first. Often the verb of saying is dropped entirely, and you rely on context and the paragraph break to know who is speaking. This is an area where reading a lot teaches you more than any rule.

Longer sentences

Quotes pile up in conversation and narrative. Watch the nested と.

先生せんせいはteacher「明日あしたのtomorrow's試験しけんはexam難むずかしいかもしれないからsince it may be hardよくwell勉強べんきょうしておくように」と"make sure to study" (quote)言いいsaid and私わたしにto me「大丈夫だいじょうぶだと"it'll be all right,"思おもうよ」とI think" (quote)付つけ加くわえたadded
The teacher said, "Tomorrow's exam may be hard, so make sure to study well," and added to me, "but I think you'll be fine."
彼かれがheなぜwhy突然とつぜんsuddenly引ひっ越こしたのかmoved誰だれにもto anyone分わからなかったがwasn't clear but近所きんじょのneighbourhood人ひとたちはpeople借金しゃっきんがdebtsあったらしいとapparently there were (quote)噂うわさしていたwere rumouring
No one knew why he'd moved so suddenly, but the neighbours were rumouring that he apparently had debts.

Reported speech in a news style

警察けいさつによるとaccording to the police男おとこはthe man「財布さいふをwallet落おとしたのでsince I dropped探さがしていた」とwas looking for (quote)話はなしておりis saying, and事件じけんとのwith the incident関係かんけいはconnectionないものとみられているis thought to be none
一方いっぽうmeanwhile、 近所きんじょのneighbourhood住民じゅうみんからはfrom residents「前まえにもbefore too同おなじ男おとこをsame man見みかけた」というsaw (quote)声こえもvoices too上あがっているare being raised
According to the police, the man says he was looking for a wallet he had dropped, and he is believed to have no connection to the incident. Meanwhile, some residents of the neighbourhood say they have seen the same man before.

Key points

  • と closes a quote and is followed by 言う, 思う, 聞く and so on.
  • Quotes keep their own grammar: no tense shift, no pronoun change.
  • 〜と思う: I think. 〜って: casual と. 〜という: called / that.
  • 〜かどうか reports a yes/no question; 〜か reports a question word.
  • Plain form + そうだ = I heard that.

Drill these patterns

Short example sentences for the points in this lesson: