immersionlog

Clauses that describe nouns: the key to long sentences

Anything can be put in front of a noun to describe it, including a whole sentence. This one idea is how Japanese packs long, detailed phrases into a single noun, and learning to read it is the most useful reading skill there is.

About 8 minutes to read

If you learn only one thing from this course, make it this. It is how Japanese turns "The dog that I saw in the park where I used to go to school" into a single, neat noun phrase, and it's the main reason long Japanese sentences look so hard.

The rule

In English, descriptions of a noun can come after it: "the book that I bought yesterday".

In Japanese, everything that describes a noun goes before it, and that includes whole clauses.

昨日きのうyesterday買かったbought本ほんbook
the book (that I) bought yesterday

Read it left to right: "yesterday bought book". The clause 昨日買った ("bought yesterday") sits right before 本 and describes it. There is no "that", no "which", no "who". Just the clause, then the noun.

It works with every kind of predicate

Verbs:

毎日まいにちevery day走はしるruns人ひとperson
a person who runs every day

Adjectives (you already do this):

高たかいtall山やまmountain
a tall mountain

Nouns take の (である in formal writing):

学生がくせいstudentのwho is妹いもうとyounger sister
my younger sister, who is a student

な-adjectives take な:

静しずかなquiet町まちtown
a quiet town

You've been doing exactly this since the lesson on adjectives. A clause is just a longer version.

Past, negative, anything

The verb inside the clause can be in any plain form, with its own tense and negative:

昨日きのうyesterday見みたsaw映画えいがmovie
the movie I saw yesterday
食たべないdon't eat人ひとperson
a person who doesn't eat
彼かれheが 作つくったmade料理りょうりdish
the dish he made

The tense inside the clause is its own: it describes the time of the clause relative to now. 食べた人 is "the person who ate"; 食べる人 is "the person who eats".

What is the noun doing inside the clause?

This is where reading takes practice. The noun at the end is also a part of the clause in the sense that the clause has a gap where it would go:

私わたしIが 昨日きのうyesterday買かったbought本ほんbook
the book I bought yesterday私が昨日___を買った. The book fills the gap of the thing bought (the object).
昨日きのうyesterday本ほんbookを 買かったbought人ひとperson
the person who bought a book yesterday___が昨日本を買った. The person fills the gap of the one who bought (the subject).
私わたしIが 昨日きのうyesterday本ほんbookを 買かったbought店みせshop
the shop where I bought a book yesterday私が昨日___で本を買った. The shop fills the gap of the place.

The same noun can fit different gaps, and Japanese does not mark which. You work it out from meaning. As you read, ask: "If I took the noun out and put it back in the clause, where would it go?"

Reading long ones, right to left

Here's a phrase that would give any beginner a headache:

友達ともだちfriendが 昨日きのうyesterday買かったbought本ほんbookを 読よんでいるis reading人ひとperson
the person who is reading the book that a friend bought yesterday

Break it up. Start from the end:

  1. The main noun is 人 (person).
  2. The clause on it is 友達が昨日買った本を読んでいる ("is reading the book that a friend bought yesterday").
  3. Inside that, 友達が昨日買った describes 本.

So the structure is a series of boxes, each inside the next:

[ [ 友達が昨日買った ] 本を読んでいる ] 人

Read the noun first, then work outward: "a person ... who is reading a book ... that a friend bought yesterday". The English comes out in reverse order. That is the trick: the order of the Japanese is the opposite of the order of the English you'd produce.

が becomes の in clauses

Inside a describing clause, the subject can take の instead of が. They mean the same, but の is common in writing:

私わたしIの's好すきなliked食たべ物ものfood
the food I like
母ははmotherが 作つくったmade料理りょうりdish
母ははmotherの's作つくったmade料理りょうりdish
the dish my mother made

You can't use は inside this kind of clause, because は is reserved for the main sentence's topic.

Examples with the noun being a word like こと, 時, 所

Many clauses end in a general word like 人, 時, 所, 物, 事, 日. These words mean "person", "time", "place", "thing", "matter", "day", and they let you describe nearly anything:

初はじめてfirst会あったmet日ひday
the day we first met
勉強べんきょうするstudy所ところplace
a place to study
彼かれheが 言いったsaidことthing
what he said

Words like こと and の, which have almost no meaning on their own, turn any clause into a noun. The next lesson shows how.

「という」: a clause that names

When the content is a name, a title or a reported idea, という ("called that") connects it:

「ドラえもん」Doraemonというcalledアニメanime
an anime called Doraemon
日本にほんJapanに 行いくgoというthat夢ゆめdream
the dream of going to Japan

Longer sentences

This is the skill to practise most. Each passage below is built from nested clauses; the method is always to find the final noun and peel backwards.

昨日きのうyesterday駅えきでat the station会あったmet友達ともだちがfriend (subject)先月せんげつlast month私わたしがI貸かしたlent本ほんをbook (object)まだstill読よんでいないとhasn't read (quote)言いったsaid
The friend I met at the station yesterday said he still hasn't read the book I lent him last month.
父ちちがfather毎朝まいあさevery morning散歩さんぽのwalk's途中とちゅうでon the way買かってくるbuys and brings駅前えきまえのin front of the station小ちいさなパン屋やのsmall bakery's焼やきたてのfreshly bakedパンはbread家族かぞくみんなのthe whole family's楽たのしみですis something to look forward to
The freshly baked bread from the little bakery in front of the station, which Father buys on his morning walk, is something the whole family looks forward to.

Clauses that name an idea with という:

彼かれがhe突然とつぜんsuddenly会社かいしゃをcompany辞やめるというthat he'd quit話はなしをstory聞きいてhearing、 誰だれもがeveryone驚おどろいたwas surprised
Everyone was surprised to hear the news that he was suddenly quitting the company.

A paragraph of clauses

私わたしがI初はじめてfor the first timeその町まちをthat town訪おとずれたvisitedのは(nominalizer)十年前じゅうねんまえのten years ago's秋あきだったwas autumn
駅えきをstation出でるとwhen I left目めの前まえにright before my eyes広ひろがっていたのはwhat lay spread out古ふるいold木造もくぞうのwooden家々いえいえがhouses並ならぶline up静しずかなquiet通とおりでstreet and地元じもとのlocal人ひとがpeople毎朝まいあさevery morning開ひらいているkeep小ちいさな市場いちばだったwas a small market
It was autumn ten years ago that I first visited that town. What lay before my eyes when I left the station was a quiet street lined with old wooden houses, and a small market that local people open every morning.

Key points

  • Everything that describes a noun comes before it, including a whole clause.
  • The clause is in plain form; nouns use の, な-adjectives use な.
  • No "that / which / who" word. The noun just follows the clause.
  • To read one, find the final noun, then work backward.
  • The subject of the clause can use が or の, never は.
  • という connects a name or an idea to a noun.

Drill these patterns

Short example sentences for the points in this lesson: