immersionlog

Offering, suggesting and asking opinions

ましょうか and ようか for offers, たらどう and てはどう for suggestions, でも for 'how about something like', and how to ask 'what shall we do?' without sounding pushy.

About 4 minutes to read

Offering: ましょうか

Polite stem + ましょうか = "shall I...?". It's an offer to do something for the other person.

荷物にもつluggageを 持もちcarryましょうかshall I
Shall I carry your luggage?
窓まどwindowを 開あけopenましょうかshall I
Shall I open the window?

The answer is お願いします (please do) or 大丈夫です (it's fine, no need).

Casual: volitional + か. 持とうか? 開けようか?

手伝てつだってhelpあげようかshall I
Want me to help?

Shall we? ましょうか with a group

The same form, with "we" implied, becomes "shall we?":

そろそろ 帰かえりgo homeましょうかshall we
Shall we head home?
何なにwhatを 食たべeatましょうかshall we
What shall we eat?

Inviting: ませんか

A reminder. ませんか invites, gently: "Won't you...?"

一緒いっしょtogetherに 行いきgoませんかwon't you
Won't you come with me?

Suggesting: たらどう

Past form + らどう(ですか) = "how about doing...?", more direct than an invitation.

病院びょういんhospitalに 行いったgoらどうhow aboutですか 
Why don't you go to the hospital?
少すこしa little休やすんだrestらどうhow about
Why not rest a bit?

て-form + はどう is similar and softer:

先生せんせいteacherに 聞きいてaskはどうhow aboutですか 
How about asking the teacher?

Noun + は どう

For a noun, は どう (ですか) = "how about...?":

コーヒー は どうhow aboutですか 
How about some coffee?
明日あしたtomorrowは どうhow about
How about tomorrow?

Use にしましょう / にしよう to pick one:

じゃあ ラーメン にしようlet's go with
Okay, let's go with ramen.

Suggestion with でも

Noun + でも = "something like... maybe".

お茶ちゃteaでもor something飲のみdrinkませんか 
Shall we have some tea or something?

It softens the suggestion: not necessarily tea, but something of that sort.

Advice: ばいい / といい / ほうがいい

ば-form + いい or たらいい = "it would be good if you...":

先生せんせいteacherに 聞きけaskばいいshould
You should just ask the teacher.
早はやくearly寝ねるsleepといいit'd be good
You'd better sleep early.

ほうがいい (earlier lesson) is a stronger "had better".

"What shall we do?"

Open questions:

  • どうしましょうか — What shall we do?
  • どうすればいいですか — What should I do?
  • どうしたらいいでしょうか — What should I do (I wonder)?
  • 何にしますか — What will you have?
どうすればwhat to doいい です か 
What should I do?

Longer sentences

Offers and suggestions chain naturally in a conversation. Read the exchange as a dialogue.

重おもそうですねlooks heavy、 荷物にもつをluggage持もちましょうかshall I carry
ありがとうございますthank youでもbut大丈夫だいじょうぶですit's fineすぐそこですからit's just over there, so
それならin that case、 代かわりにinsteadお茶ちゃでもtea or something飲のみませんかwon't you drink
いいですねgood、 近ちかくにnearbyいいgoodカフェがcaféあるのでsince there isそこにthereしましょうlet's choose
You look weighed down. Shall I carry your luggage? Thank you, but it's all right. It's just over there. In that case, how about having some tea or something instead? Sounds good. There's a nice café nearby, so let's go there.
疲つかれているならif you're tired少すこしa little休やすんでみてはhow about trying to restどうですかhow is it
無理むりしてforcing yourself倒たおれたらif you collapse大変たいへんですからit'd be terrible今日きょうはtoday早はやくearly帰かえったwent homeほうがいいですよhad better
If you're tired, why not try resting a little? It would be terrible if you pushed yourself and collapsed, so you'd better go home early today.

Key points

  • ましょうか: "shall I / shall we". ませんか: "won't you?"
  • たらどう / てはどう: "how about doing".
  • Noun + は どう / でも: "how about / something like".
  • ばいい / といい: advice.

Drill these patterns

Short example sentences for the points in this lesson: